Reviews

We certainly have gained quite the reputation over 25 years! Check out some reviews below that were pulled directly from our Facebook page. A HUGE thank you to all of our amazing customers for leaving such great feedback!

“Came into town and got a dozen gobs…..pure heaven!
Highly recommend!!!!!” – Michele D.

“Toni and the rest of Custom Cake’s bakery staff were incredible! I called with a large custom cookie order. The cookies were ready in just over 24 hours. Each cookie was hand decorated to perfectly match the photo that I provided. The sugar cookies were such a huge hit and were devoured so quickly, that I had to call back and place a double order. Toni and her crew were again more than happy to accommodate in a timely manner. I also purchased a few gobs, brownies, and no-bakes that were equally delicious! I know that I will be a returning customer in the near future and highly recommend Custom Cake and Cookies!” – Liz J.

“Last Friday I picked up the cookie tray and apricot rolls we ordered from Custom Cakes and Cookies. I wasn’t able to get a picture of the cookie tray because as soon as it was in the door, everyone was digging in. The cookies are really good and there is a wide variety. The apricot rolls are really good as well. Thank you, Toni Penna Illuzi for providing a wide variety of delectable cookies for us to enjoy this holiday season! We will definitely be ordering again!” – Paula T.

“The cream puff tower was my daughter’s wedding cake. When she chose the type of cake, I didn’t know where to begin. I showed Toni a picture, she said “no problem “ and the deal was done! Complete faith and confidence in Toni and her abilities! When we walked into the reception hall, WOW! If you’re looking for something different, something unique, Custom Cakes & Cookies is the place to go!!” – Katy H.

“A month before our wedding, our original bakery cancelled on us. In a panic, I found Tori and Custom Cake and Cookies .net. They were so accommodating and saved me when I was in need! They provided a beautiful and delicious wedding cake for our special day. I am so happy we found them, as we couldn’t have asked for anything better. THANK YOU for a fabulous job and adding to our wedding day!” – Rachel L.